Phillip McCallum
MEDIATOR AND ARBITRATOR

Phillip McCallum
LawPay Logo
Phillip McCallum

A popular and effective mediator, Phillip McCallum brings experience, creativity, and credibility to the mediation table. Litigation attorneys and their clients appreciate Phillip's ability to build relationships and rapport with people from all walks of life.

Phillip brings to every mediated dispute a wealth of experience in litigation and in business and organizational management in facilitating valuable problem-solving for individuals and businesses.

The Birmingham native and past president of the Alabama State Bar attended Auburn University, graduated from the University of Alabama in Birmingham, and received his law degree from Cumberland School of Law. He is admitted to practice law in Alabama, Texas, Oklahoma, and West Virginia, and he is a member of the Alabama Academy of Attorney Mediators.

Phillip's value as a mediator is enhanced by his experience in leading a successful trial firm and in litigating disputes on behalf of both businesses and individuals. That experience provides a solid foundation for his effectiveness in achieving settlement in a wide variety of areas, including:

  • Personal injury, medical malpractice and wrongful death

    Phillip McCallum has over 30 years of experience handling catastrophic personal injury, medical malpractice, and wrongful death cases and mediations stemming from a wide variety of causes, whether auto accidents, 18-wheelers, product liability, workplace accidents, toxic torts, pharmaceuticals, burns, medical malpractice, medical devices, industrial accidents, exposures, fires, or other causes.

  • Automobile and trucking accidents

    Phillip McCallum has over 30 years of experience handling catastrophic personal injury and wrongful death cases stemming from a wide variety of vehicle accidents, including cars, trucks and 18-wheelers.

  • Fraud and bad faith

    Phillip McCallum has dealt with fraud and bad faith cases and mediations including consumer fraud, bank fraud, insurance fraud, bad faith failure to pay, bad faith failure to investigate, consumer finance, mortgage lending, retail installment contracts, lender liability, collateral protection, warranties, and predatory lending.

  • Class actions, mass torts and complex litigation

    Cases involving multiple claimants present some unique challenges when it comes to settlement.  Having a mediator who can generate creative solutions and help the parties navigate the distinctive pitfalls associated with these cases is important.

  • Insurance and business disputes

    Insurance and business disputes turn on interpreting complex and complicated contracts, but they are a breach of contract cases at their heart.  Regardless of the amount in controversy, exploring the contract terms, the facts at issue, and the applicable law are critical to a thorough analysis and understanding of the issues involved in mediating such disputes.  Phillip uses his many years’ experience in the courtroom to enhance his effectiveness in mediating disputes of this type.  But he doesn’t let either interfere with your ability to negotiate your case.  These types of cases include acquisitions, buy-sell agreements, stock purchase agreements, shareholder agreements, covenants not to compete, insurance coverage disputes, equipment purchases, real estate, leases, and other similar matters.

  • Construction

    Construction cases are never simple.  They often involve multiple contracts, multiple parties, numerous contributing factors, complicated damage calculations, and a multitude of expert witnesses.   Mediating these cases requires a mediator who is experienced in construction matters so that he can quickly understand and assess the issues at play.   Phillip McCallum has managed and mediated numerous large and complex construction disputes, both before and after lawsuits or arbitration demands have been filed. 

  • Employment

    Employment matters are rarely simple to resolve.  They are multifaceted and turn on policies, best practices, laws, regulations, and sometimes contracts, but also emotions, feelings, and relationships.  The ability to connect with people is one of the most important skills in mediating these types of disputes.  Phillip is not only an experienced litigator and mediator, but he has real-world experience as a manager, managing large offices Including a quasi-state entity.  He has dealt with issues including, wage and hour, overtime, leave, Family Medical Leave Act, discrimination, Title VII, sex discrimination, sexual harassment, hostile workplace, race discrimination, religious discrimination, age discrimination, failure to hire, wrongful termination, demotions, employee discipline, employee benefits, hostile environment, workers compensation, employment agreements, and other employment-related matters.

Phillip has also been very active in giving back to his community through his pro bono leadership and civic and charitable causes (listed below).

Calendar Your Next Mediation or Arbitration

Phillip's case manager, Lacey McCaleb, will contact you on receipt of your Appointment Request.


Does your preferred date appear to be booked? Please contact Lacey at her office number 256-734-3542, ext. 6, by her cell number 205-495-1299, or by email to see whether we can accommodate your schedule.

Phillip McCallum on mediation and arbitration

(articles coming soon)

September 3, 2025
Litigation is designed to resolve disputes, but the journey through discovery, motions, and trial can be long and expensive. Increasingly, lawyers and their clients are recognizing that early mediation can achieve the same resolution—without the heavy cost of prolonged litigation. The question is: how do you know when to recommend early mediation? Here are a few key signs that early intervention may be the right move: 1. The Core Facts Are Not in Serious Dispute If liability or the main issues of the case are largely clear, there’s little to gain from prolonged litigation. Early mediation can focus on resolving damages or terms of settlement rather than waiting months for the court process to unfold. 2. The Costs of Discovery Outweigh the Benefits Complex cases often involve expensive discovery: depositions, expert witnesses, and electronic data review. When the costs of discovery threaten to exceed the potential gain, early mediation provides a way to save resources while still reaching a fair outcome. 3. Preserving Relationships Matters In employment disputes, business partnerships, or family-owned company conflicts, the ongoing relationship between parties is valuable. Early mediation can reduce hostility and maintain a foundation for future collaboration. 4. Insurance and Risk Management Considerations When insurers are involved, early resolution often aligns with their interest in cost containment. Identifying cases where liability exposure is evident can prompt insurers and defense counsel to welcome mediation sooner rather than later.  5. Courts Are Backlogged Post-pandemic court delays continue to affect many jurisdictions. Early mediation can provide certainty in months instead of years, giving clients closure and predictability. Recommending early mediation isn’t about rushing resolution—it’s about recognizing when litigation will add more cost than value. By identifying the right cases for early intervention, attorneys can deliver efficiency, preserve relationships, and provide real value to clients.
August 13, 2025
"Learn advanced settlement enforcement strategies in mediation & arbitration—consent awards, escrow, liquidated damages & cross-border planning."
Show More

Professional Memberships

American Bar Association

Alabama State Bar: Past President (2012-2013)

Alabama Academy of Attorney Mediators

Birmingham Bar Association

National Conference of Bar Presidents

Southern Conference of Bar Presidents

Recent Presentations

"Mediation: Mistakes to Avoid - Beginning to End" (CLE webinar co-presenter), Alabama Defense Lawyers Association, April 18, 2023

"Mistakes to Avoid from Beginning to End in ADR/Mediation" (CLE webinar co-presenter), Birmingham Bar Association, October 28, 2022 | Member comments

Bar Admissions

Alabama, 1988

Texas, 2002

Oklahoma, 2003

West Virginia, 2004

Education

J.D., Cumberland School of Law, Samford University, 1987

B.S. (Political Science), The University of Alabama at Birmingham, 1984

Community Leadership

Vestavia Hills Parks and Recreation Foundation: Past Board Member

City of Vestavia Hills Substance and Abuse Committee: Past Chair

Triumph Services: Past Board Member

Vestavia Hills Club Wrestling coach

An Environment Conducive to Settlement

While we function effectively via Zoom or other online settings, our conference rooms provide a peaceful, comfortable setting for your in-person mediation or arbitration. Take a virtual tour.